[]   Your account

Choosing a repairer for a car insurance claim

Choosing a repairer for a car insurance claim

Damage to your car, whether it’s cosmetic or mechanical, is going to cost money to repair. When you make a claim, most insurance providers offer to get the damage fixed using one of their approved repairers. But what if you want to choose your own repairer?

Here’s what to consider when choosing a repairer for a car insurance claim.

Daniel Hutson
From the Motor team
minute read
posted 19 FEBRUARY 2020

Choosing a repairer

When you make a car insurance claim, you’ll need to agree with your insurance provider on who will repair your damaged vehicle. There are two possibilities:

An approved repairer
An approved repairer is contracted and approved by an insurance provider to carry out repairs on your car, in the event of a claim.

Not only do insurance providers prefer it if you use a repairer approved by them, they may also impose certain limits and conditions if you don’t. For example, some will only make a courtesy car available if you use a repairer provided by them.

A repairer of your choice
You might decide to go with a repairer of your own choosing. It might be that they offer a high-quality service you’re happy with, or it could be that their location is easier to reach.

The right to choose your own repairer

Not only are you free to choose your own repairer, it’s your legal right to do so.

The Motor Vehicle Block Exemption Regulations is an EU law which gives car owners the right to freely choose any repairer or body shop to repair their vehicle. Under your UK car insurance repair rights, you’re not obliged to go with an approved repairer chosen by your insurance provider if you don’t want to.

Pros and cons of choosing your own repairer

There are some advantages and disadvantages to choosing your own repairer.


  • You get to choose who fixes your car.
  • Your choice of repairer might be more local to you.
  • An approved repairer might not fit original parts – check your policy to see what it says about this.


  • Many comprehensive car insurance policies include a courtesy car - but typically that’s only if you use an approved repairer.
  • Your insurance provider won’t usually guarantee repairs unless they’ve been done by one of their approved repairers. And if further damage is done to your car while it’s being repaired, you might not be covered.
  • Your insurance provider might charge an additional sum on top of your excess if you choose your own repairer.
  • Your insurance provider might not agree to pay the full cost of the repairs, if they believe it would have been cheaper to use an approved repairer.

If you do decide to choose your own repairer, you’ll need to get an estimate of the repair costs and send it to your insurance provider. In order to claim, the estimate must be approved by your insurance provider before repair works begin.

Regardless of whether you use an approved repairer or one you've chosen, read your policy documents carefully so you understand exactly what terms and conditions apply to repairs.

If you’re unhappy with repairs carried out by an approved repairer

If you’re not satisfied with the repairs done by an approved repairer, or the way your insurance provider dealt with your claim, you can ask the Financial Ombudsman Service to investigate your complaint.

Find a car insurance deal to suit you

If you’re looking for a great car insurance deal, comparing with us could help you save time and money.

We independently compare a wide range of insurance providers to help you find a car insurance deal you’re happy with.

We’ll show you policies based on price, level of cover, add-ons and payment terms, making it easier to select the right deal for you.

Looking for a quote?

Compare car insurance in minutes to see if you can save

Get a quote
Compare car insurance Get a quote

comparethemarket.com uses cookies to offer you the best experience online. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of cookies. If you would like to know more about cookies and how to manage them please view our privacy & cookie policy.